top of page

Book Review | Size

Greg McNeilly

Updated: 7 days ago

 
Size by Vaclav Smil
Size by Vaclav Smil

SIZE: How it Explains the World | Vaclav Smil, William Morrow Publishing (2023), 304p.


​In "Size: How It Explains the World," author Vaclav Smil explores the significance of scale in various aspects of life. From the nanoscale to the global level, this book delves into the impact of size on biology, technology, society, and the environment. As an energy and environmental science expert, Smil uses his unique perspective to reveal the profound effects of scaling on our world.


The book begins by introducing the concept of scale and its importance in understanding various phenomena. Smil effectively illustrates how size influences everything from materials’ strength to transportation systems’ efficiency. He presents fascinating examples, such as the fact that spider silk’s strength-to-weight ratio is greater than steel’s, highlighting the remarkable properties of natural materials.


One of the book's most compelling aspects is its examination of the role of size in biology. Smil discusses the evolution of species, explaining how their size affects their survival, reproduction, and interactions within ecosystems. He also explores the implications of size for human health, demonstrating how body mass index (BMI) can mislead us in assessing health risks. These insights offer readers a fresh perspective on the interconnectedness of life and the importance of considering scale in scientific research.


Smil's discussion of technology is equally captivating. He investigates the limitations and potential of various inventions, analyzing the constraints size imposes on engineering feats such as bridges, buildings, and aircraft and the challenges faced in miniaturizing electronic devices. His explanations of the physics behind these concepts are accessible and engaging, making them enjoyable for experts and non-experts alike.


The section on social and economic issues is particularly thought-provoking. Smil illuminates topics like urbanization, population growth, and global trade, emphasizing the significance of scale in addressing these challenges. He argues that understanding the relationship between size and complexity is essential for effective decision-making in politics and business.


Throughout the book, Smil presents numerous graphs and diagrams to support his arguments. While they are generally helpful in illustrating key concepts, some may need to be more complex or dense for casual readers. However, this minor flaw does little to detract from the overall value of the text.


"Size: How It Explains the World" is a stimulating and informative read offering a new perspective on the world. Vaclav Smil's extensive knowledge and engaging writing style make this book appealing to a broad audience interested in science, technology, and sustainability. By examining the impact of scale on various domains, Smil encourages readers to think critically about the consequences of size in our daily lives and inspires us to consider innovative solutions to our challenges.


QUOTES:

  • "The only thing that matters is the size of the gap between what we want and what we have."

  • "Scale is the silent partner in nearly every human endeavor."

  • "When things get bigger, they get different."

  • "There is no such thing as a free lunch, but there is such a thing as a free ride."

  • "The biggest room in the world is the room for improvement."

  • "The only person who likes change is a wet baby."

  • "If you want to make a good first impression, start with a good last impression."

  • "When you're through changing, you're through."

  • "The optimum size of a company can fit in a single room."

  • "The best way to predict the future is to invent it."


OUTLINE:

I. Introduction

  • The importance of understanding size and its impact on various aspects of our lives

  • The need to recognize the significance of scale in addressing global challenges

II. The Physics of Size

  • The fundamental principles of scale and their applications

  • The differences between linear and nonlinear scales

  • The concept of self-similarity and its relevance in nature and technology

III. Biological Scales

  • The diversity of sizes in living organisms

  • The impact of size on biological processes and functions

  • The challenges of scaling in medicine and healthcare

IV. Technical Scales

  • The limits and opportunities of scaling in engineering and technology

  • The tradeoffs between size, performance, and efficiency

  • The role of materials science in overcoming scalability challenges

V. Social and Economic Scales

  • The influence of size on social structures and institutions

  • The implications of scale in economics and finance

  • The challenges of managing and governing large-scale systems

VI. Environmental Scales

  • The impact of human activities on the environment and the planet's resources

  • The role of scale in climate change and sustainability efforts

  • The need for a holistic approach to environmental management

VII. Conclusion

  • The importance of understanding and harnessing the power of scale

  • The potential benefits of scaling up or down in various contexts

  • The call to action for responsible and sustainable practices in a world of increasing complexity and interconnectedness.


bottom of page